Which marketing brings my best leads? Count the phone calls, not just the forms
To see which marketing brings your best leads, count every lead by source, including phone calls, not only form submissions. Call tracking shows which channel each call came from. Then divide what you spend on each channel by its leads to get cost per lead, and compare channels on that number and on how many of those leads become customers.
Many businesses judge their marketing by website visits or form submissions. Both leave out something important. Visits are not customers, and for many businesses, especially ones that sell to trades, industry or local customers, a large share of serious buyers pick up the phone instead of filling in a form. If you cannot see those calls, the channel that drives them looks worse than it is.
Why phone calls go missing
Google Analytics records what happens on your website. When someone reads your page and then dials the number on it, the visit ends and the call happens somewhere Analytics cannot see. Even a click on a "tel:" link only shows that someone tapped the number, not whether they called, got through, or became a customer.
So a Google Ads campaign that brings in ten calls a week and two forms looks, in Analytics alone, like it brings two leads.
How call tracking fixes it
Call tracking services such as CallRail use dynamic number insertion: your website shows a different phone number depending on where the visitor came from. Someone who arrives from a Google ad sees one number, someone from a Google search sees another. When they call, the service knows the source and records the call, including:
- the source and medium (for example Google, paid or organic),
- whether it was the caller's first call or a repeat,
- whether the call was answered,
- the page they were on, and for ad visitors, the ad click.
Calls are forwarded to your normal number, so nothing changes for whoever answers the phone.
Count leads the same way for every channel
Build one simple table for the last month or quarter, with a row per channel:
- Forms: form submissions from that channel, from Google Analytics (mark your form submission as a key event so it is counted).
- First-time calls: from your call tracking. Leave out repeat calls, which are usually existing customers.
- Total leads: forms plus first-time calls.
- Spend: what the channel cost you. For Google Ads, read it from the Ads account or from Google Analytics if the two are linked.
- Cost per lead: spend divided by total leads.
For channels you do not pay for per click, such as organic search, cost per lead is not really zero; it is the time and content that earned those rankings. Still, it is useful to see how many leads they bring next to paid channels.
Read the table carefully
- A cheap lead is not always a good lead. If you can, note which leads became customers. A channel with a higher cost per lead can still be the best one if more of its leads buy.
- Check the answered rate. If a channel's calls are often missed, the problem may be staffing at certain hours, not the marketing.
- Look at the landing page. If one ad's visitors call but rarely fill in the form, the form on that page may be the weak point.
- Allow for small numbers. Five leads a month can swing by chance. Compare over a quarter before cutting a channel.
Common gaps to check
- The tracking number is missing from some pages, so those calls show up as "direct" or not at all.
- The form submission is not marked as a key event in Google Analytics, so forms are undercounted.
- Google Ads is not linked to Analytics, so spend and leads cannot be lined up.
- Calls from your Google Business Profile use your main number, so they cannot be told apart from everything else. Most call tracking services offer a separate number for it.
Once forms and calls are counted together, the question "which marketing works?" usually gets a clear answer within a few weeks.